Overcrowding, Inefficiencies, and Human Rights Concerns Call for Urgent Prison Reform in India
Image Source: iPleaders
A damning report on the living conditions in Indian prisons from the Supreme Court Committee on Prison Reforms highlights the urgent need to address congestion through accelerated legal processes. The committee’s final report to the Supreme Court, presided over by retired Supreme Court Justice Amitava Roy, emphasizes the glaring discrepancy between jail conditions and the requirements set out in the Model Jail Manual of 2016. Fast and effective action is required for this catastrophic situation to be fixed.
According to data as of November 30, 2018, there were 1,341 prisons in India, with an occupancy percentage of 122%. The issue of overcrowding is prevalent throughout the country and affects various institutions, including sub-jails and district jails. The committee’s conclusions make clear the urgent necessity to deal with this situation and guarantee that the treatment of prisoners complies with accepted norms and human rights standards.
Prison overcrowding is a recurring issue, and the committee’s thorough investigation of the matter has uncovered a wide range of contributing reasons. These elements, taken together, depict a picture of a correctional system that is straining to deal with the growing prison population and the difficulties it poses:
Slow Infrastructure Expansion in Prisons: One important aspect is the slow infrastructure growth in prisons. The number of convicts has been rising steadily, but jail infrastructure has not kept up. Overcrowding is worsened by this delay in infrastructure construction.
Lack of Aggressive Measures: According to the committee, there haven’t been enough aggressive efforts to upgrade or expand current jail facilities. Numerous problems, such as budgetary restrictions, administrative lethargy, and administrative obstacles, might be blamed for this delay.
Unnecessary Arrests for Minor Offenses: The overcrowding problem is worsened by the unjustified arrest and imprisonment of people for very minor and non-violent offenses. Potentially lessening the pressure on jails, such instances may be dealt with by alternative sanctions like fines, community service, or probation.
Justice System Delays: From the time of the investigation until the time of the trial, the criminal justice system’s delays greatly contribute to the problem of overcrowding. Inmates may spend a lot of time in overcrowding during protracted pretrial detentions, which are frequently the result of case backlogs.
The committee’s initial investigation concentrated on 12 states and emphasized the grim realities of jail overpopulation in India. District jails, where many prisoners are initially housed, were found to have the highest rates of overcrowding—a startling 148 percent. At 129 percent and 106 percent, respectively, overcrowding was especially severe in the central and sub-prisons.
The final summary of findings, published in December 2022, emphasizes the committee’s commitment to tackling many aspects of prison reform. Prison overpopulation, the disturbing problem of unnatural deaths within correctional facilities, the treatment and rights of transgender inmates, and the complicated issues of those who are on death row are among them.
The committee’s establishment in September 2018—led by Justice (retd) Amitava Roy—marked a significant development in identifying and addressing the urgent need for prison reform in India. In line with the values of justice and human rights, it continues to make efforts to address structural issues within the criminal justice system, improve circumstances, and treat prisoners fairly. A total overcrowding rate of 139 percent was found after the committee’s investigation of male jails in 12 jurisdictions. The chapter titled “Overcrowding in Prisons” goes into depth about how this number varied greatly from jail to jail, ranging from around 104 percent to as high as 181 percent.
In its recommendations, the committee has placed a strong emphasis on the necessity of bolstering the Undertrial Review Committee (UTRC) process as a necessary first step in resolving the overcrowding situation. The main duty of the UTRCs, which are formed in each district, is to assess the cases of inmates awaiting trial and criminal defendants who have either served their sentences or are eligible for release owing to bail, remission, or other legal requirements. These committees consider each case individually and offer recommendations for the release of qualified prisoners, assisting in reducing prison overpopulation.
The committee’s suggestion to strengthen the UTRCs’ efficiency is in line with the significance of quick and impartial evaluations of convicts’ cases to make sure individuals who are eligible for release aren’t kept behind bars unnecessarily. The correctional system may make significant progress toward resolving the issue of overcrowding and improving the general conditions within Indian jails by optimizing the UTRC process.
Despite periodic building work in a few prisons, the committee noted that the general condition of the sleeping quarters remained appalling. It emphasized, in particular, the appalling circumstances in the barracks, where female prisoners and their kids, ranging in age from a few months to six years, were crammed together, putting them at danger for a variety of health and safety issues. The committee also found that the proportion of detainees awaiting trial in Indian jails was much higher than that of those who had been convicted. It emphasized the significance of speedy legal proceedings to deal with this situation. The committee acknowledged the need for more prison employees on a national level and encouraged swift hiring for open posts.
In addition, the group emphasized that the courts underutilized key legislative remedies, such as fines, probation, and admonition, as alternatives to imprisonment. Promoting their usage might help reduce prison congestion and support inmates’ reintegration into society. The Supreme Court has set the following hearing on September 26 as part of its ongoing investigation into the conditions in Indian prisons, demonstrating its commitment to resolving these pressing issues.
Team Profile
Latest entries
News4 September 2023ISRO’s Strategic Approach: Enhancing Efficiency and Scientific Discovery with Pragyan Rover on the Moon
News4 September 2023India’s Solar Space Observatory and Sun Exploration Mission, Aditya-L1
News3 September 2023KARNATAKA’S GRUHA JYOTI SCHEME: Providing Relief and Savings to Household Consumers Amid Rising Energy Demand
News2 September 2023A Significant Development in Indian Education: NCERT’s Designated University Status
